Carmelite Nuns in Texas

The question is whether some Church leaders have intuitive intolerance? I accept this question, since what some of the Church leaders did to the innocent nuns in Texas seems unethical and unjust. The final cause of the Catholic Church is peace. According to the Lord, “Peace I leave with you” (Jn 14: 27). “Peace” is defined as “the freedom from civil clamor and confusion” (Webster’s Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 1660).Unfortunately, some Church leaders do not believe in the Lord and do not spread His peace. For example, a Carmelite sisters said that some Church leaders attempted “to divide our community.” Thus, because Church leader who tries to separate Carmelite sisters from the peace of Christ and causes confusion has intuitive intolerance, some Church leaders have intuitive intolerance. 

The material cause of the Catholic Church is dialogue. “Dialogue” is defined as “a conversation between two or more people” (Webster’s Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 623).  Unfortunately, some Church leaders reject dialogue and will have a conversation with others. For example, a Carmelite sister said, Church leaders were “not interested in the documented evidence.” Further, she said, “Christophe Pierre received the documentation but seemed to just ignore it.” Thus, because Church leader who rejects dialogue and refuses to communicate with Carmelite sisters has intuitive intolerance, some Church leaders have intuitive intolerance. 

The formal cause of the Catholic Church is love. According to St. James, “If you really keep the royal law found in Scripture, ‘Love your neighbor as yourself,’ you are doing right" (2: 8). “Love” is defined as “the attraction for a person who triggers admiration” (Webster’s Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 1340). Unfortunately, some Church leaders are not loving and do not keep “the royal law found in Scripture” (2: 8). For example, a Carmelite sister said, “The defamatory story that [Church leaders] put out in the press and on social media about us is absolutely false.” Further, “intuitive intolerance” is defined as “the immediate emotional reactions or disapproval of out-group practices as ‘different,’ often without reflective reasoning” (Maykel Verkuyten, “The Psychology of Intolerance,”  July 29, 2020). Unfortunately, some Church leaders have “immediate disapproval” of Carmelite nuns based on the nuns’s “different practices” and not based on “reflective reasoning.” Thus, because every Church leader who rejects “the royal law found in Scripture” (2: 8), slanders, works to destroy the reputation of Carmelite nuns, and shows “disapproval” to Catholic nuns has intuitive intolerance, some Church leaders have intuitive intolerance.

The principal agent of the Catholic Church is the Lord. According to the Psalms, “The Lord is my strength and my defense” (Ps 118:14). Unfortunately, some Church leaders do not respect the principal agent of the Church. On February 26, 2018, Bishop Michael Olson in Fort Worth, Texas, said, “Let me teach you.” Here Bishop Olson is trying to replace the Lord as the principal agent of the Church and claiming to have better teaching abilities that He does. Further, on February 23, 2018, Bishop Olson said, “I only hope that I am close to finding out how many of my parishes are made up of true Catholics mindful of my authentic teaching office.” Here Bishop Olson is commanding obedience to himself and discouraging the defense of the Lord. Thus, because every Church leader who asserts his dominance over the Lord and commands obedience to himself has intuitive intolerance, some Church leaders have intuitive intolerance. 

The preparing agent of the Catholic Church is the Blessed Mother. According to St. Luke, “Mary had done everything required by the Law of the Lord” (Lk 2: 39). Mary prepares us to obey her Son and Our Lord. Unfortunately, some Church leaders do not accept the example of Mary. For example, the Carmelite sisters received a letter commanding them to reject the Lord’s role as the principal agent and Mary’s role as the preparing agent. On November 29, 2024, Sister Simona Brambilla wrote, “This Dicastery for Institutes of Consecrated Life writes to inform you that after having carefully examined your ‘votum’ and that of the President of the Carmelite Association of Christ the King, has determined that the community of the Discalced Carmelite Monastery of Arlington, Texas, is extinct.” The term “votum” sends a message to the Carmelite sisters that they are no longer partners in the business of the Catholic Church. Thus, because every Church leader who rejects the example of Blessed Mother and treats religious sisters as business partners has intuitive intolerance, some Church leaders have intuitive intolerance. Further, every Church leader who tells “consecrated members of the Church” (Canon Law 573. 1) that they are “extinct,” dead, and destroyed has intuitive intolerance, some Church leaders have intuitive intolerance. 

The assisting agents of the Catholic Church are Church leaders. According to Canon Law (204.2), “This Church, established and ordered in this world as a society, subsists in the Catholic Church, governed by the successor of Peter and the Bishops in communion with him.” Unfortunately, some Church leaders are not helping the members of the Church. For example, a Carmelite sister said, “Our canon lawyers and civil lawyers were very surprised at how everything went because standard procedures were not followed.” Thus, because every Church leader who does not follow “standard procedures” and does not help members of the Church has intuitive intolerance, some Church leaders have intuitive intolerance.

The first instrumental agent of the Catholic Church is Canon Law. A “canon” is define as “a decree, decision, or regulation made by ecclesiastical authority” (Webster’s Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 328). For example, Canon 129.1 states, “Those who are in sacred orders are, in accordance with the provisions of law, capable of the power of governance.” Thus, because everyone without sacred orders who pretends to have the power of governance in the Church has intuitive intolerance, and because Sister Simona Brambilla is a Church leader lacks sacred orders and pretends to have the power of governance in the Church, some Church leaders have intuitive intolerance. 

The second instrumental agents of the Catholic Church are communication tools, such as letters, phone calls, emails and social media posts. Unfortunately, some Church leaders are not using the instruments and communication tools of the Catholic Church. For example, Kassi Marks at the Texas Right to Life group writes, “Bishop Olson is blocking some people from his Twitter page who dare to question him” (kassiblog.blogspot.com). Further, Kassi Marks writes, “I have requested a meeting with Fort Worth Bishop Michael Olson on the [pro-life] matter about a dozen times. I have written a certified letter, tweeted, and emailed him. Others have made that same request of him. He has, as I expected, ignored those requests.” Further, on August 8, 2018, parishioners at St. Martin de Porres church “gathered over 600 signatures seeking the return of Fr. Kirkham. Bishop Olson rejected the petition.” Thus, every Church leader who blocks pro-life workers on X, who rejects certified letters and emails from pro-life workers, and rejects the conclusion of 600 Catholics has intuitive intolerance, some Church leaders have intuitive intolerance. 

The first counseling agents of the Catholic Church are bishops. According to Canon Law (425.2), “As diocesan Administrator a priest is to be elected who is outstanding for doctrine and prudence.” Unfortunately, some Church leaders lack “doctrine and prudence.” For example, Kassi Marks writes, “The Texas Conference of Catholic Bishops is clearly backtracking and trying to undo some of what Olson has done.” The Texas Conference of Catholic Bishops is actively fixing the mistakes caused by Olson’s recklessness and mistrust. Further, a Carmelite sister said, “Authority without integrity is no authority at all” (Catholic Vote April 22, 2024). Thus, because every Church leader who lacks doctrine, prudence and integrity and who pretends to be a counseling agent of the Church has intuitive intolerance, some Church leaders have intuitive intolerance. 

The second counseling agent is Jean Twenge, a psychology professor at San Diego State University, who writes, “One of the best ways to combat entitlement is to be grateful for what you already have” (2009: 241). Every Church leader should be very thankful for good priests, holy nuns, and loyal college students who want the Latin mass. But because every Church leader who is not grateful for good priests, holy nuns and loyal college students has intuitive intolerance, some Church leaders have intuitive intolerance 

History shows that the Catholic Church can be a loving place. Jean Twenge writes, “Love creates a secure base for a child and connection that they can count on” (Narcissism Epidemic, 2009, 192). Through the centuries the Church has been loving and provided a secure base for missionaries, artists, universities, hospitals, loyal Catholics and monks and “consecrated members of the Church” (Canon Law 573. 1). Unfortunately, some Church leaders do not provide “a secure base” for “consecrated members of the Church” (Canon Law 573. 1). There are four examples in history. First, Kassi Marks writes on Feb. 27, 2018, “Oh, Bishop Olson. Please stop. There are simply no facts to support the allegations made against the Texas Right to Life.” A pro-life lawyer told Olson to destroying her secure connection in the Catholic Church. Second, on March 6, 2014, the Fort Worth Star Telegram newspaper wrote, “Bishop Michael Olson of the Roman Catholic Diocese of Fort Worth prohibited the traditional Latin Mass at the college.” Olson did not provide loyal Catholics a secure base in the Church. Third, on August 8, 2018, John Walsh wrote, “There is no justification for removing Father Kirkham as the Pastor of St. Martin de Porres because there are no allegations that his ministry has negatively affected his parishioners” (Fort Worth Star Telegram). Olson disconnected a good priest from a Catholic parish, because Olson did not like how the good priest complained about criminal priests. Fourth, Olson said on December 2, 2024, “It is gravely wrong for Catholics knowing to assist at these Masses” at the Carmelite monastery. Bishop Olson is not providing a secure base for Carmelite sisters in the Catholic Church and telling Catholic to not be connected to the Carmelites. Thus, because every Church leader who does not provide pro-life workers with security, does not help loyal Catholics get connected to the Church, destroys the reputation of a good priest in order to protect criminals, and discourages people from attending mass at the Carmelite convent has intuitive intolerance, some Church leaders have intuitive intolerance.

I shall now use my freedom to choose my two favorite reasons from all the good reasons above. I prefer the formal cause and the instrumental agent. I shall now express my preferences with a command. Every Church leader who disobeys “the royal law found in Scripture” (James 2: 8) and pretends to be “capable of the power of governance” (Canon 129.1) without orders has intuitive intolerance. And the Carmelite sisters in Texas have contacted Church leaders who disobey “the royal law found in Scripture” (James 2: 8) and pretend to be “capable of the power of governance” (Canon 129.1) without orders.

The first objection is to say that all Church leaders are logical and ethical. According to Tom Gorman who wrote in March 1, 2018, “Olson in Fort Worth is a great theologian whose chancery is one of the most conservative places in America” (shorturl.at/J68IM). 

The reply to the first objection is to say that “In an eight page decision, the Congregation for Clergy, which is a Dicastery of the Holy See, concluded that Fr. Kirkham’s suspension was both invalidly inflicted and procedurally improper” (shorturl.at/Zvt24). Olson, a Church leader, made a decision concerning a holy priest that was “invalid” and illogical, “improper” and unethical.

Final remarks. Some Church leaders just don’t like the Carmelite nuns, because the Carmelite nuns are Catholic and different. Thankfully, the Lord is the principal agent of the Catholic Church and He “takes vengeance on His foes” (Nahum 1: 2). “Vengeance” is defined as “the infliction of punishment in return for an injury or offense” (Webster’s Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 2540). 


© By Theodore Faulders, May 25, 2026.