Logical Analysis. Deduction
The final causes of Plato's story are the “upper world” (516 b, 517 b and 517 d), the “region of the intelligible” (517 b), “true reality” (519 b), and the “Islands of the Blest” (519 c). Thus, because some people are not familiar with “the upper world” and the “Islands of the Blest,” some people are like prisoners stuck in a cave.
The material cause of Plato's story is a prisoner. Plato writes, “Prisoners so confined would have seen nothing of themselves or of one another” (515a). A “prisoner” is defined as “a person held under restraint; a captive” (Webster's Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 1804). Further, Plato writes, “Here they have been from childhood, chained by the leg and also by the neck” (514a). Thus, because some people are like “prisoners” (515a) who are “confined” (515a) in a cave and “chained” (514a) by their legs and necks, some people are like prisoners stuck in a cave.
The formal cause of a prisoner is confusion. Plato writes, “Would he not be perplexed?” (515d). The term “perplex” is defined as “to disturb mentally especially so as to make impossible clear or decisive thinking on the matter at hand” (Webster's Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 1684). Thus, because some people are “perplexed” (515d), “mentally disturbed” (1684), and find it “impossible” (1684) to think clearly, some people are like prisoners stuck in a cave.
The principal agent cause of a prisoner is “the Lord of light” and “Parent of intelligence and truth” (517 c). Plato writes in The Phaedo, “All men would admit that God… is immortal, never perishes” (106 d). The “Lord” is defined as “one having power and authority over others; God, Christ” (Webster's Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 1337). Further, Plato writes, “Without having had a vision of this Form no one can act with wisdom, either in his own life or in matters of state” (517c). Thus, because some people lack a “true view” (515 c) of the “Lord of light” (517c), remain “perplexed” (515d), lack “decisive thinking” (1684) and lack “wisdom” (517c) about themselves and politics, some people are like prisoners stuck in a cave.
The preparing agent of a prisoner is philosophy. Plato writes, the prisoners “must be made to climb” (519d) out of the cave. Prisoners “must” (519d) study philosophy in order to leave the life of a “captive” (1804). Further, Plato writes, “Now all this is very natural in students of philosophy such as I have described” (539a). “Philosophy” is defined as “a love or pursuit of wisdom” (Webster's Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 1698). “Philo” is the Greek term for love and Sophia is the Greed goddess of wisdom. When Sophia smiled, the confusion and “mental disturbances” went away. Philosophy students who appreciate Plato's story about prisoners in a cave in his Republic, chapter seven, are eager scholars who had their chains removed by philosophy. Thus, because some people “must be made” (519d) to study philosophy and learn to appreciate the “Parent of intelligence and truth” (517 c), some people are like prisoners stuck in a cave.
The assisting agent for a prisoner is a helpful philosopher. Plato writes, “There will be no injustice in compelling our philosophers to have a care and providence of others” (520b). “Care” is defined as “serious attention accompanied by caution, pains, wariness, personal interest or responsibility” (Webster's Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 338). A philosopher is a person who gives “serious attention” (338) to prisoners in a cave and feels both “caution” and “responsibility” (338). Further, Plato writes, “Now consider what would happen if their release from the chains and the healing of the unwisdom should come about in this way” (515c). Philosophers are students who wish to “release” prisoners “from the chains” and to “heal” (515c) their mental disturbances. Thus, because some people need the assistance of helpful philosophers who are caring and serious, some people are like prisoners stuck in a cave.
The instrumentals agent of a prisoner are the “chains” (514a) of “envy” (516d). “Envy” is defined as the “painful or resentful awareness of an advantage enjoyed by another joined with a desire to possess the same advantage” (Webster's Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 760). Plato writes, “Would our… prisoner be likely to covet those prizes or to envy the men exalted to honor and power in the cave?” (516d). Thus, because some people hate the “advantage enjoyed by another” (760), and because some people cannot explain why they fear the “advantage enjoyed by another” (760), some people are like prisoners stuck in a cave.
The counseling agent of a prisoner is Plato. Plato writes, “A sensible man will remember that the eyes may be confused in two ways: by a change from light to darkness or from darkness to light” (518a). A “sensible” person will not laugh at prisoners stuck in chains, since the sensible and practical person will remember the “painful” (515c) chains that he had before he was “released” (515c) and moved “from darkness to light” (518a) by “philosophy” (539a). Further, Plato writes, “You must go down, then, each in his turn, to live with the rest and let your eyes grow accustomed to the darkness” (520 c). His recommendation is difficult to accept, since healing belongs to the activity of exiting the cave and harmful seems to belong to moving “from light to darkness” (518a). However, philosophers must go down into the cave and assist the prisoners stuck in chains. Thus, because some people need the assistance of “sensible” and practical philosophers in order to “from darkness to light” (518 a), some people are like prisoners stuck in a cave.
Logical Analysis. Induction
The inductions of a prisoner are conclusions from the sights and sounds of shadows. Plato writes, “In every way, such prisoners would recognize as reality nothing but the shadows of those artificial objects” (515c). A “shadow” is defined as “comparative darkness or shade within defined bounds” (Webster's Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 2083). Prisoners are “perplexed” (515d) and “mentally disturbed” (1684) by the “chains” (514a) of “envy” (516d) and “prevented” (515b) from a “true view” (515d) of the “Lord of light” (517c). A prisoner highlights the pride in his ability to name the goods of fortune, such as riches, power, fame, pleasure, beauty and honor. Further, a prisoner downplays his inability to define and appreciate the goods of fortune. Thus, because some people accept the perplexing “shadows” (515c) and “miseries of this life” (517d) and reject the “healing” (515c) property of “true reality” (519b), some people are like prisoners stuck in a cave.
The history of a prisoner is traumatic. Plato writes, “If they [the prisoners in the cave] could lay hands on the man who was trying to set them free and lead them up, they would kill him” (517 a). A prisoner a cave historically kills a helpful philosopher and refuses to become released from chains. History shows that philosophers regularly have tough times, bad days and cruel deaths. Glaucon, the character who is listening to Plato’s story in The Republic, responds to the history and says, “Yes, they would” (517 a). Further, Socrates (470-399 BC) mentions the tragic history of philosophers in The Apology and says that helping prisoner break the chains of envy and “resentment” (28 a) has led to “the destruction of many good men before me” and “there is no prospect that I shall be the last victim” (28 b). Further, Aristotle (384-322 BC) left Athens rather than be punished by death and said, “I do not wish that Athens should sin twice against philosophy.” Further, St. Joan of Arc (1412-1431) kindly released France from the chains of England and then was cruelly punished by leaders in both France and England. Rather than congratulate her on her strategic brilliance, the leaders in France and England chained her to a wooden block and put her in irons. Thus, because history shows that some people are cruel to helpful philosophers who wish to remove their chains of envy, some people are like prisoners stuck in a cave.
The analogy of a helpful philosopher is that he is similar to a bee in a hive. Plato writes, “We have brought you into existence for your country's sake as well as your own, to be like leaders and king-bees in a hive” (520b). A “hive” is defined as “a place divided primarily into worker bees and drones, ruled by the queen” (The Random House Encyclopedia, 1977, p. 494). Thus, the analogy of Plato stands and we can say that a philosopher who knows how to break the chains of envy is capable of ruling a community just as a queen bee is able to rule a hive of worker bees and drones.
A sign that a person is a prisoner is how he laughs at helpful philosophers. Plato writes, “They would laugh at him and say that he had gone up only to come back with his sight ruined” (517a). A prisoner stuck in cave “laugh” at helpful philosophers. “Laugh” is defined as “an expression of scorn or mockery” (Webster's Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 1277). Thus, because some people scorn and “laugh” at helpful philosophers, some people are like prisoners stuck in a cave.
Signs that a person is a philosopher is how he reluctant to help and feels awkward when helping. Plato writes, “It is no wonder if those who have reached this height are reluctant to manage the affairs of men” (517c). The first sign that a person might be a philosopher is that he is “reluctant” (517c) and hesitant to help prisoners and to become community leaders. Further, Plato writes, “Nor is it at all strange that one who comes from contemplation of divine things to the miseries of human life should appear awkward and ridiculous” (517e). The second sign that a person might be a philosopher is that he loves to appreciate “divine things” and “appears awkward and ridiculous” when explaining the cause of the chains on prisoners. Thus, because some people feel “awkward and ridiculous” when trying to help others in chains, some people are philosophers.
The motive of a prisoner is compulsion. Plato writes that a helpful philosopher should “drag him away forcibly” (515e). “Force” is defined as the “exercise of strength or power; compulsion and any power that compels an individual follow a will not his own” (Webster's Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 887). A prisoner has chains with a power that is “not his own” (887). A helpful philosopher can explain the nature of the chain and show how to get “his own” power back. Thus, because some people need to be dragged away “forcibly” (515e0 from their chains and feel compelled to “follow a will” that is not their own (887), some people are like prisoners stuck in a cave.
The motive for climbing out of the cave is reasonable. Plato writes, “They must be made to climb the ascent to the vision of Goodness, which we called the highest object of knowledge” (519 c). “Reason” is defined as “to use the faculty of reasoning so as to arrive at conclusions” (Webster's Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 1892). If a prisoner is “set free” (515c) and “released” from his “chains” (515c), then he will to use his “faculty of reason” (1892) and “arrive at conclusion” (1982) about “divine things” (517d), “true reality” (519b), the “upper world” (516b), and the “Lord of light” (517c). Further, Plato writes, “They must be made to climb the ascent to the vision of Goodness, which we called the highest object of knowledge” (519d). If a prisoner is assisted by a helpful philosopher and encouraged to “climb the ascent” out of the cave, then he will arrive at conclusions about “Goodness” which Plato says is the “highest object of knowledge” (519d). Thus, because some people cannot climb out of the cave and cannot arrive at conclusions about “true reality” (519b) and “Goodness” (519d), some people are like prisoners stuck in a cave.
The passion of an ex-prisoner is pity. Plato writes, “If he called to mind his fellow prisoners… he would surely think himself happy in the change and be sorry for them” (516 c). “Pity” is defined as sympathetic heartfelt sorrow for one that is suffering physically or mentally or that is distressed or unhappy” (Webster's Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 1726). A helpful philosopher who arrives at a “true view” (515d) of “divine things” (517d) and the “Lord of light” (517c) will feel “sorrow” for prisoners who are “mentally disturbed” (1684) by the three chains of admiration for another person, hatred for the other person's “advantage” (760), and “fear” (527e) that the advantage of the other person will never come to be. A philosopher knows that if a person concludes that the “Lord of light” (517c) is “the cause of all” (516c), then he will be “released” (515c) from the chains and become thankful. Thus, because some people trigger the “pity” (516c) and “heartfelt sorrow” (1726) of philosophers, some people are like prisoners stuck in a cave.
The percentage of people who prisoners is 100%. Plato writes, prisoners are “like ourselves” (515a). Everyone has the chains of envy and everyone needs a helpful philosopher to drag him out of the cave. Each person experiences a secret admiration for a talented figure which gets mixed up with hatred for the talented figure and a fear of the talented figure. If a person does not learn how to be thankful for the talented figure, then he will be chained up and dragged down into a pit of despair. Proof: Socrates had secret admirers who killed him. Thus, because everyone has the “perplexing” (515d) chains of described by Plato, some people are like prisoners stuck in a cave.
Freedom
I shall now use my freedom to review the good reasons above. I shall now use my freedom to choose my two favorite reason. I have decided that I prefer the assisting agent cause and the induction. I shall now use my freedom to make an enthymeme. Because every person needs the assistance of “sensible” (518a) and practical philosophers in order to move “from darkness to light” (518a), and because all prisoners are “perplexed” (515d) and “mentally disturbed” (1684) by the “chains” (514a) of “envy” (516d) and “prevented” (515b) from a “true view” (515d) of the “Lord of light” (517c), some people are like prisoners stuck in a cave.
Objections
There are four objections to the conclusion that some people are like prisoners stuck in a cave. First, climbing out of the cave is repulsive and painful. Plato himself acknowledges this and writes that a person leaving the cave “will suffer sharp pains” and feel “irritated.” The response to the first objection is to say that some body builders have a classic maxim which states: “no pain, no gain.” This maxim refers to the fact that we need to go beyond our comfort level in order to reach superior goals. For example, sometimes we need to get a painful shot from a doctor in order to become healthy or we need to sit through an irritating line at the post office in order to send gifts. Similarly, we need to deal with the pain and irritation that comes when talking about how we envy a few people with advantages in order to appreciate their loving presence in our lives.
Second, a person who successfully climbs out of the cave becomes a person who appears “ridiculous” and silly. The response to the second objection is to state that a free person might seem ridiculous, but a person chained by secret hatred for another figure with an advantage is genuinely ridiculous and silly. Plato writes that a person healed of his chains “would far sooner be on earth as a hired servant in the house of a landless man than go back to his old beliefs and live in the old way” (516d). It is ridiculous to prefer the perplexing chains of envy over the vision of the Islands of the Blest.
Third, a person who leaves the cave will put his life in danger. Plato writes, “If anyone [outside the cave who] tried to loose another [in the cave] and lead him up to the light… they would put him to death.” The response to the third objection is to quote Socrates who said, “Wherever a man's station is, whether he chosen it of his own will, or whether he has been placed at it by his commander, there it is his duty to remain and face the danger without thinking of death or any other thing except disgrace” (28d). Worrying about death is secondary. Every helpful philosopher has the “duty” (28d) to think about how to release the chains and how to become thankful for another figure with an advantage. And death for a person without chains leads to the Islands of the Blest.
Fourth, Plato is wrong, since the chains is not envy alone. There are eight deadly sins and chains which prevent a person from “true view” (515d) of the “Lord of light” (517c). St. John Cassian (360-435) writes, “There are eight principal faults which attack mankind; first gluttony, secondly fornication, thirdly avarice, fourthly anger, fifthly dejection, sixthly acedia, seventhly boasting, and eighthly pride” (Conference of Abbot Serapion, ch. 2). The response to the fourth objection is to posit that envy is underneath the eight deadly sins of Cassian, since envy has chains that traumatize a perplexed person leading to intemperance, promiscuity, theft, wrath, despair, feeling stuck, bragging and pride. Proof: a virtuous person is thankful for philosophy and his healing release from chains, bond and irons.
Final Remarks
Everyone needs philosophy in order to get over the chains of resentment and despair. The good news is that if a person does not wish to donate ten hours to the study of Plato's Republic, then he can simply donate fifteen minutes a day to praying the rosary in order to get the same results. Better yet, a person can do both studying the Republic and praying the rosary and really become a helpful person to others stuck in chains.
© By Theodore Faulders, March 6, 2006.