Aristotle's Syllogistic. From the Standpoint of Modern Formal Logic. By Jan Lukasiewicz. Oxford. Clarendon Press. 1951. 222pp.

The question is whether a syllogism is good? I accept, allow, approve and welcome this question since Aristotle focused on the syllogism in his logical works and his works are very influential in the history of science. The final cause and goal of a syllogism is to bring about new knowledge from old knowledge. For example, we all know that “a dolphin is a whale” and that “a whale is a mammal.” What is new and interesting, however, is to realize that “a dolphin is mammal.”

The material cause and stuff of a syllogism are three simple propositions. There are three formal causes and unique features that belong to every syllogism: (1) a universal proposition is the major premise on top, (2) an affirmative proposition is the minor premise in the middle, and (3) the figure is figure one.

The principal agent and person responsible for a syllogism is every logic student who tries to arrange three simple propositions into figure one. The preparing agent is that which prepares a logic student to use a syllogism which includes his previous work with subjects, predicates, simple and compound propositions, universal and particular propositions, affirmative and negative propositions, conversion, obversion and figures. A person who wishes to use a syllogism in order to bring new knowledge from old knowledge may be assisted by a logic teacher who has made many mistakes with syllogisms in the past and knows how to correct those mistakes. The syllogism itself is an instrumental agent and tool that allows a person to create scientific demonstrations and strong conclusions.

What does a person see when using a syllogism? A person who works with a syllogism will see a universal proposition on top, an affirmative proposition in the middle, and the middle terms in figure one.

The history of a syllogism starts with Aristotle (384-322 B.C.) who discovered the three features of a syllogism while studying logic at Plato’s school “The Academy” in Athens. Because of his discovery of the syllogism as well as other tools in logic, Aristotle is described as “The man who built the foundation of a civilization” (Laughlin, The Story of Aristotle, 1995: 1). According to a contemporary historian of logic, “Aristotle’s views on the syllogism and the structure of an axiomatic system has remained a part of every methodology of deduction right to our own day” (Bochenski, History of Formal Logic, 1961: 74).

A syllogism is analogous to a blender. A blender is a tool in the kitchen that is capable of making a healthy new drink from old ingredients, such as ice cream, eggs, chocolate powder and milk. Similarly, a syllogism is a tool in a person’s memory that is capable of making healthy new knowledge from old knowledge, such as “dolphin,” “whale” and “mammal.” A sign that a syllogism is good and worthy of our attention is the fact that syllogisms bring peace, makes sense, sound logical and work smoothly.

The motive for using a syllogism is reasonable, since it is reasonable to use a logical tool in order to have new knowledge. The motive for using a syllogism might be natural, since a syllogism naturally works. However, the motives for using a syllogism do not involve chance, compulsion, or anger, since a syllogism requires confidence and patience. The passions that are triggered when using a syllogism are several. A logic student may feel fear in relation to such things as “simple propositions,” “figures,” and “conversion.” Or a logic student might feel anger since a syllogism seems so easy in theory but difficult when actually using one. Or a student might feel courage since he knows that logic class is one of the most difficult classes on a college campus and welcomes the challenge. Lastly, a logic student might feel joy, because a syllogism is a logical instrument that brings about new knowledge. The percentage of logicians and scientists who use syllogisms is 100%.

After reviewing the above deliberation process, I will now choose (a) the analogy and (b) the passions as my favorite reasons for accepting the conclusion that “a syllogism is good.” My two choices allow me to make the following command. A syllogism is good, because a syllogism (a) brings healthy new knowledge like a blender and (b) triggers the feeling of joy.

I shall now make the following argument. Every thing that (a) brings healthy new knowledge and (b) triggers the feeling of joy is good. A syllogism is a thing that (a) brings healthy new knowledge and (b) triggers the feeling of joy. Therefore, a syllogism is good.

A historian may object that Aristotle’s syllogism was valuable during the Medieval (800-1200) and Renaissance (1200-1600) but is useless today, since the predicate calculus of Gottlob Frege (1848-1925) is a superior version of deduction that serves computer programs in a way that is much better than syllogisms. Jan Lukasiewicz, the famous mathematical logician from Crakow, Poland, responds to this objection and writes, “The syllogistic of Aristotle is a system the exactness of which surpasses even the exactness of a mathematical theory, and this is its everlasting merit.” (Aristotle’s Syllogistic from the Standpoint of Modern Formal Logic, 1951: 131).

A logician may also complain that the syllogism is a small part of Aristotle’s teachings on formal logic and that there are many other topics in logic that deserve more attention, such as modal propositions and relationships. This complaint is weak, as Bochenski points out, since “Aristotle’s masterpiece in formal logic is his syllogistic” (Bochenski, History of Formal Logic, 1961: 98).

A young logician may wonder if the time devoted to the study of syllogisms will prevent him or her from studying more exciting problems in contemporary philosophy. My response is to say that one of the topics in cognitive science today is called “Logical Reasoning Systems.” David McAllester, a contemporary philosopher at Toyota Technological Institute in Chicago, writes, “Logical reasoning systems derive sound conclusions from formal declarative knowledge… and have a rich history, starting with Greek syllogisms and continuing through the work of many prominent mathematicians such as Descartes, Leibniz, Boole, Frege, Hilbert, Godel and Cohen” (“Logical Reasoning Systems,” The MIT Encyclopedia of the Cognitive Sciences, 1999: 491). Thus, devoting time toward the understanding of syllogisms will open doors to current problems in philosophy.

Final remarks. Understanding a syllogism is good, since a syllogism is a tool of logic that brings new knowledge, feelings of joy, the exactness of mathematical logic, and introduces a student to contemporary problems in philosophy. Similarly, the syllogism is the “masterpiece” of Aristotle’s logic. 

© By Theodore Faulders, January 18, 2017.