The question is whether St. Joan of Arc (1412-1432) is the glory of France and all of Christendom? I consent to investigate this question, since she had an “extremely significant military career” (29).
Logical Analysis: Deduction
The final causes of St. Joan’s activities are three. Devries writes, “She said that she had
two commissions for which she had been sent by the King of Heaven: one to raise the siege of Orléans, the other to lead the king to Reims for his coronation and consecration” (45). The terms “commission” is defined as “an authority granting certain powers or privileges and commanding the performance of certain acts or duties” (Webster’s Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 457). St. Joan of Arc was commanded to perform two duties. Further, Devries writes, “After she raised the siege of Orléans, Joan… had become la Pucelle d’Orléans, the Maid of Orléans” (91). Further, Devries writes, “Joan of Arc had fulfilled the second task of her mission: she had crowned the dauphin king of France” (128). Further, Devries writes, Joan wishes “to rid her land of the evil forces which occupied it” (162). The term “rid” is defined as “to clear or free obstructions or encumbrances” (Webster’s Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 1952). Thus, because St. Joan of Arc successfully “raised the siege of Orléans,” “lead the king to Reims for his coronation,” (45), and cleared France of obstructions, St. Joan of Arc is the glory of France and all of Christendom.The formal causes of St. Joan are three. Devries writes, “Joan was a warrior, a soldier, and a general” (ix). A “warrior” is defined as “a man engaged or experienced in warfare” (Webster’s Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 2578). Further, Devries writes, “Joan of Arc was a soldier, plain and simple” (3). Further, Devries writes, “She had become a captain, going to command in war” (49). And Joan was “a leader of the French army” (4). Thus, because St. Joan of Arc was a “warrior” “experienced in warfare,” a “soldier, plain and simple,” and a general “going to command in war,” St. Joan of Arc is the glory of France and all of Christendom.
The principal agent of St. Joan is the Lord Jesus Christ. Joan said, “The Lord wishes me to do this” (38). Further, Devries writes, Joan “had her Lord Who would make a road for her” (41). Further, Devries writes, “Joan of Arc was a devoted believer in the Christian God, the One Who sends her on a military mission” (2). Thus, because St. Joan of Arc followed the “wishes” (38) of the Lord, trusted that the Lord “would make a road for her” (41), and felt sent by the Lord “on a military mission” (2). St. Joan of Arc is the glory of France and all of Christendom.
The preparing agent of St. Joan is St. Michael the Archangel. Devries writes, “Saint Michael appeared to her when she was young and afraid, and afterwards Saint Michael taught her much and proved himself to her so that she believed firmly that it was him. Above all, he told her that should should be a good child and that God would help her” (35). St. Michael prepared her to become “a warrior, a soldier, and a general” (ix) and “told her only to conduct herself well and to go to church often” (35). Further, Devries writes, “She often had personal and visible communication with St. Michael” (1). Thus, because St. Joan of Arc “believed firmly” in St. Michael the Archangel, tried to “be a good child” (35), went “to church often,” (35), and “often had communication with” St. Michael (1), St. Joan of Arc is the glory of France and all of Christendom.
The assisting agents of St. Joan are angels, saints and friends. Devries writes, “She often had personal communication with… a great host of angels” (1). Further, Devries writes, “Saint Catherine and Saint Margaret visited her and gave her advice on how to proceed on her mission” (35). Further, St. Joan said, “The help of the King of Heaven does not come through love of me, buy from the petition of Saint Louis and Saint Charlemagne” (70). According to St. Joan, King St. Louis IX and Blessed Charlemange “petitioned” and begged the Lord, the King of Heaven, “to have pity on the town of Orléans” and “to raise the siege of Orléans” (45).
Further, Devries writes, “Jean de Metz remained a constant companion throughout her life and carried on her mission after her death” (37). Jean de Metz was her friend and “gave her men’s clothing to make her ride more comfortable” (40). Further, Devries writes, “Jean, duke of Alencon, would become her staunchest ally and best friend” (70). Further, “Etienne de Vignolles, La Hire,… felt that the English could be defeated, but that they needed inspiration” (28). Thus, because St. Joan of Arc received the assistance of “a great host of angels” (1), “Saint Catherine and Saint Margaret” (35), St. Louis, King of France, and Blessed Charlemange, King of Franks, Jean de Metz (37), Jean, duke of Alencon (70), and Etienne de Vignolles (28), St. Joan of Arc is the glory of France and all of Christendom.
The instrumental agents of St. Joan are prayer, Catholic sacraments, a standard, a set of armor, a special sword, and miracles. Devries writes, “Jean Waterin, a childhood friend, testified that Joan would draw herself aside and speak with God” (34). St. Joan used prayer to give her strength. Further, Devries writes, “Robert de Baudricourt arranged for her to be exorcised” (40). St. Joan used the Catholic sacraments of confession, communion and an exorcism to grow closer to the Lord, the “King of Heaven” (70). Further, Devries writes, “Joan designed and had made a special standard” (46). St. Joan used a “standard” and a banner that she “designed.”
Further, Devries writes, “The dauphin ordered a set of armor to be made for Joan. It was a full harness and fit to her body” (47). St. Joan used “a set of armor,” since she was “a warrior, a soldier, and a general” (ix). Further, Devries writes, “Joan knew about the sword’s presence in the ground behind the altar of the monastic chapel at Saint Catherine de Fierbois” (48). St. Joan used a special sword from the chapel at the monastery of Saint Catherine de Fierbois” (48) Further, Devries writes, “Joan solved these problems with miracles” (67). Joan was “a saint” (41) who used miracles to solve problems. Thus, because St. Joan of Arc used prayer “to speak with God” (34), Catholic sacraments including an “exorcism” (40), a standard which she “designed” (46), a set of armor from her friend Jean de Metz “the dauphin” (47), a “special” (47) sword with “five crosses” (47), and specific miracles, St. Joan of Arc is the glory of France and all of Christendom.
The miracles of St. Joan are five. Devries writes, “Her purity so confused the soldiers who fought and lived around her that they changed their feelings about her… And it seemed that this was almost a miracle” (31). Further, Devries writes, “When they were about to ambush her, they were unable to move from their places, and thus Joan escaped” (42). Further, Devries writes, “At her trial, Joan was asked to recall the circumstances of the sword’s discovery. Her judges did this to try to cast doubt on the miraculous nature of this event” (48). Further, Devries writes, “In a moment, the wind changed and became favorable” (67). Further, Devries writes, “By March 29, 1430, she was in Lagny dated there by the miracle of her restoring the life of a baby” (162). Thus, because the purity of St. Joan of Arc “confused the soldiers” (31), her enemies were “unable to move” and ambush her (42), her sword was obtained by a “miraculous event” (48), the wind “became favorable” (67) and allowed her to cross the river near Checy, and she restored “the life of a baby” (162), St. Joan of Arc is the glory of France and all of Christendom.
The counseling agent is St. Joan. On March 22, 1429, St. Joan wrote to Henry VI, the King of England, and said, “I am sent from God, the King of Heaven, to chase you out of all of France” (64). St. Joan is very clear about her principal agent and her final cause: to serve the King of Heaven and to clear France of obstructions. Further, St. Joan wrote to King Henry VI and said, “You shall never hold the kingdom of France from God, the King of Heaven, the son of St. Mary” (64). St. Joan assists the Lord to clear France of evil forces. Further, on April 29, 1420, St. Joan talked with Jean de Dunois (1402–1468), a French military leader, and said, “The counsels of our Lord God is surer and wiser than yours” (70). Jean de Dunois trusted Joan and supported her.
Further, on May 7, 1429, St. Joan addressed an English commander and “shouted,” “Glasdale, Gladale, give in, give in to the King of Heaven!” (84). St. Joan counseled Sir William Glasdale (died 1429) to “give in” and surrender to the Lord. Further, on March 23, 1430, St. Joan wrote a letter to “the heretical Hussites who were fighting against the Catholic lords in Bohemia” and said, “You ruin the sacraments of the Church, you rend the articles of Faith, you destroy churches, you smash and burn the statues which have been erected as memorable monuments, you massacre Christians simply because they have kept the true Faith” (160). St. Joan told the heretics to stop destroying “the sacraments of the Church,” “the articles of Faith,” “churches,” “statues,” and “Christians,” since they are instrumentals agents used to “rid the land of the evil forces” (162). Thus, because St. Joan of Arc told Henry VI that she wishes to serve the “King of Heaven” (64) and to clear France of obstructions, because she Jean de Dunois to trust “the counsels of our Lord” (70), because she told Sir William Glasdal “to give in” to the Lord, and because she told the Hussites to stop “destroying” (160) the instrumental agents of Catholic soldiers, St. Joan of Arc is the glory of France and all of Christendom.
Logical Analysis: Induction
St. Joan made observations about French citizens and military soldiers. Devries writes, “The kingdom was becoming occupied, not only physically but also in the minds of most French men and women” (22). French citizens felt they were losing their country and wanted “to rid the land of the evil forces” (162). Further, Devries writes, “She wept for the slain English soldiers, as they had died without confession” (75). Joan understood the value of making a confession to the Lord before death. Further, Devries writes, “She encountered an English prisoner who had been hit on the head at Patay and left for dead by a Frenchman, she dismounted and received the Englishman’s confession, holding his head and comforting hi as much as she could” (115). St. Joan stopped to comfort an injured English man, held him and heard his confession. She did the right thing, since it is possible for her to substitute for a priest. St. Thomas Aquinas writes, "Confessio laico ex desiderio sacerdotis facta sacramentalis est quodammodo." – "Confession made to a layman through lack of a priest is sacramental in a certain way" (Summa Theologica, Suppl. 8, 2, Rep. 1). Further, Devries writes, “She mourned for the lost lives and took pity on the wounded regardless of whether they were English or French” (115). Thus, because St. Joan of Arc understood how the French citizens wished “to rid the land of the evil forces” (162) and appreciated how the sacraments are necessary for both French and English soldiers, St. Joan of Arc is the glory of France and all of Christendom.
The history of St. Joan is unique. Devries writes, “No person in the Middle Ages, male or female, has been the subject of more historical studies than Joan of Arc” (2). St. Joan has received the most attention from historians of the Middle Ages (500-1500). Further, Devries writes, “No single military engagement in the Hundred Years War has had more written about it than the siege of Orleans” (53). St. Joan’s “victory” (85) at Orléans has received the most attention from historians of the Hundred Years War (1337-1453). Further, Devries writes, “Joan’s renown is attached to her military ability, to the skills she had in leading men into battle against great odds and possible death” (170). St. Joan’s glory is caused by her “military ability” and leadership “skills.” Thus, because St. Joan of Arc is the most famous person during the Middle Ages, because her victory at Orléans is the most famous battle of the Hundred Years War, and because she had superior skills as a soldier and military leader, St. Joan of Arc is the glory of France and all of Christendom.
The analogy of St. Joan was created by Alain Chartier (c. 1385 – 1430) who was a French diplomat and political writer. In July 1429 Alain wrote a letter to a foreign ambassador and described the activities of Joan of Arc, the relief of the siege of Orléans, and the crowning of Charles VII at the cathedral of Our Lady of Reims. Devries writes, “Chartier compares Joan to Hector, Alexander, Hannibal, and Caesar” (88). According to Homer, “Hector was the best man among the Trojans” (Illiad, 762 BC, c. 22). Further, according to Plutarch, “Alexander esteemed it more kingly to govern himself than to conquer his enemies” (Alexander, 75 AD). Further, according to Polybius, “The soldiers had unanimously chosen Hannibal as their commander” (Histories, 150 BC, Book 3, c. 7). Further, according to Julius Caesar, “The soldiers of the thirteenth legion… all cry out that they are ready to defend their general, and the tribunes of the commons, from all injuries” (Civil Wars, 50 BC, Book 1, c. 7).
The analogy by Alain Chartier is strong. St. Joan is like Hector who was “the best among Trojans,” because “feats of arms, inspired by the Maid’s own courage, were remembered long after the siege of Orleans was raised” (83). Further, St. Joan is like Alexander who “governed himself,” because Joan “was a good Christian, and she lived as a Catholic, and she had never been found neglectful” (46). Further, St. Joan was like Hannibal who was “chosen as their commander,” because “French warriors… followed Joan with a loyalty which few soldiers in history have given their leaders” (28). Further, St. Joan was like Caesar who was defended by “the soldiers in the thirteenth legion,” because “the common soldiers had given Joan their faith and trust” (111). As a result, Alain Charier wrote about St. Joan and said, “You are the beauty, the glory, not only of France, but all of Christendom” (89). Thus, because St. Joan of Arc is similar to Hector, Alexander, Hannibal and Caesar, St. Joan of Arc is the glory of France and all of Christendom.
Three signs of St. Joan convey the message that she is the glory of France and all of Christendom. Devries writes, “She fought for command from the lack luster French military leaders, and she received it. She fought for the allegiance of the French soldiers, and she earned it. She fought for the love of the city’s inhabitants, and she gained it. The people would always remember what she had done early in May 1429” (90). Thus, because St. Joan of Arc took “command” of the “lack luster French military,” earned the “allegiance of the French soldiers,” and “gained” the love of French citizens, St. Joan of Arc is the glory of France and all of Christendom.
The motive of St. Joan is inspirational. Devries writes, “That this inspiration for military aggressiveness was to be peasant or female was probably not anticipated by any of those willing French warriors” (28). The term “inspire” is defined as “to influence, move, or guide through divine or supernatural power; to have an animating, enlivening, or exalting effect” (Webster’s Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 1170). Further, Devries writes, “Joan’s victories at Orléans and at Jargeau had continued to inspire the recruitment of soldiers, both noble and common” (103). St. Joan “influenced” (1170) “both noble and common” soldiers (103). Further, Devries writes, “She lifted up the spirits of the French to a greater hope” (89). St. Joan “animated” (1170) and “lifted up the spirits” of the French soldiers (103). Further, Devries writes, “At the head of the military was a holy woman, a living saint, whose presence guaranteed divine justification for their decision to go against the English” (118). St. Joan inspired the French soldiers with “divine power” (1170) and “divine justification” (118). Further, Devries writes, “The army and its leaders were devoted to Joan” (122). St. Joan had an “enlivening, or exalting effect” (1170) on the French soldiers. Thus, because St. Joan of Arc inspired the “French warriors” (28), inspired “noble and common” (103) soldiers, “animated” (1170) and “lifted up” (89) their spirits, “influenced” the soldiers with “divine” (118) power, and “moved” (1170) soldiers to become “devoted” (122) to her, St. Joan of Arc is the glory of France and all of Christendom.
The passions of St. Joan are courage and fear. Devries writes, “Her confidence and her devotion to her mission aided them, giving them courage in the face of obvious dangers” (40). Further, Devries writes, “The Maid and La Hire, and all of their army, joined together and attacked the English with great force and courage” (78). Etienne de Vignolles (1390-1443) was a close friend and trusted commander of Joan of Arc who was nicknamed “La Hire” and “The Wrath of God.” Further, Devries writes, “The soldiers of the king regained their courage” (83). Further, St. Joan told King Charles VII, “I will lead you into the city of Troyes, by love, or strength or courage” (126). Further, Devries writes, “The English were beginning to fear her” (95). Further, Devries writes, “She fear nothing except treason” (127). The term “treason” is defined as “betrayal of a trust or confidence” (Webster’s Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 2434). Thus, because St. Joan of Arc gave “courage” (40) to her soldiers, attacked the English “with great courage” (78), helped the soldiers to “regain their courage” (83), lead the soldiers with “strength and courage” (126), triggered “fear” in the English soldiers, and feared “nothing except treason” (127), St. Joan of Arc is the glory of France and all of Christendom.
The statistic of St. Joan is 100%. Devries writes, “Her mission was known to all” (174). The term “mission” is defined as “the act or an instance of sending” (Webster’s Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 1445). Further, Devries writes, “All want to fight with with the Maid” (121). Thus, because St. Joan of Arc was known by everyone as a person sent from the Lord, and because every soldier wanted to “fight” (121) with her, St. Joan of Arc is the glory of France and all of Christendom.
Ethical Analysis
The personality of St. Joan is confident. Devries writes, “She was confident in the divinity of her mission, and she had a fire and spirituality, which attracted soldiers to her” (51). Her confidence attracted soldiers and increased the “recruitment of soldiers” (103).
The possibility of St. Joan is that revenge probably triggered her trial. Devries writes, “There can be little doubt that revenge for La Temoille’s imprisonment, ransom and embarrassment was also a factor” (153). Georges de La Trémoille (1382-1446) “had shown disdain” (153) for Joan’s military tactics and encouraged King Charles VII to avoid rescuing Joan from prison.
The conjecture of St. Joan is that she made King Charles VII feel safe. Devries writes, “Does this mean that the dauphin felt safe enough to travel… as a result of what Joan and the French army had been able to do against the English. That must remain conjecture” (119). St. Joan and her soldiers probably made the dauphin feel safe.
The learning of St. Joan is that she taught tactics to French military leaders. “French military leaders began to adopt similar tactics to those that she employed” (179). Further, St. Joan learned from her soldiers. Devries writes, “Being ‘common’ may have allowed her to listen to others, common cannoneers, for example, and to learn from them” (52).
The reason of St. Joan is that she successfully completed her mission. Devries writes, “She completed her military mission and had sealed it with her blood” (176).
The foresight of St. Joan is that she knew that the dauphin should be crowned King Charles VII in order to decrease his dangers. Devries writes, “A reason for her opinion that when the king had been crowned and consecrated, the power of his adversaries would continue to diminish, and they they finally would not be able to hurt him or his kingdom” (121).
The circumspection of St. Joan is her ability understand tactics. Devries writes, “Alençon testified that the Maid… acted so wisely and clearly in waging war, as if she was a captain who had experience of twenty or thirty years” (52). Jean II of Alençon (1409-1476) was a French general and peer of St. Joan who admired her “experience” of “waging war.”
The caution of St. Joan is is shown by her rejection of theft and vandalism. Devries writes, “Joan strongly prohibited this and defended the place, nor did she ever allow anything to be stolen” (156). She did not like how victorious soldiers would sometimes pillage a conquered town.
Freedom
I shall now use my freedom to review the deliberation above. Hmm…. I shall now use my freedom to choose my two favorite reasons. I have decided that I prefer the principal agent and the preparing agent. I shall now use my freedom to make an enthymeme to express my choice. St. Joan of Arc “was devoted to the One Who sent her on a military mission” (2) and was prepared to become “a warrior, a soldier, and a general” (ix) by St. Michael the Archangel, St. Joan of Arc is the glory of France and all of Christendom.
Objections
There are three objections. First, an adversary might conclude that St. Joan is not the glory of France and of all Christendom, because “the English promptly put her on trial for heresy” (175). The response to the first objection is to state that the prosecutor, Jean d’Estivet (c. 13..–1438), was a Benedictine priest who focused on two silly topics: a minor theological distinction and Joan’s attire. Devries writes, Jean d’Estivet “confounded her with theological questions that even the most trained doctor of theology would have been hard pressed to answer correctly, while almost completely neglecting her military career” (176). Further, Devries writes, St. Joan was “found guilty not knowing what the definition of the Church Militant was and of wearing men’s clothing” (176). Thus, because the refutation makes mountains out of molehills, the first objection is weak.
The second objection is to conclude that St. Joan is not the glory of France and all of Christendom, because she was “on trial” (178) from January 9, 1431 to May 30, 1431. The response to the second objection is to say that the fallacy of poisoning the well has zero influence on the conclusion that St. Joan of Arc is the glory of France and all of Christendom. Devries writes, “The partiality of her trial” did not hurt her “celebrity” (178). The term “partial” is defined as “inclined to favor one party in a cause or one side of a question more than the other” (Webster’s Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 1646). Jean d’Estivet, the prosecutor of Joan’s trial, was “inclined to favor” a weak verdict, since he highlighted her ignorance of a minor theological distinction and her attire while downplaying his “jealousy” (171) of her. Why was d’Estivet jealous of Joan? Because Joan had direct communication with saints (1), angels (35), and the Lord (43) and we can be thankful for that. Further, Devries writes, Joan was honored with sainthood, a number of statues, pieces of artwork, literature, and legends award to the Maid’s memory” (178). Thus, because the fallacy of poisoning the well is supported by “partiality” (178) and “jealousy” (171), the second objection is weak.
The third objection is to conclude that St. Joan is not the glory of France and all of Christendom, because “she had not been directed on her mission from a divine source” (175). The response to the third objection is to say a paradox has zero influence on the conclusion that St. Joan of Arc is the glory of France and all of Christendom. Devries writes, “Philips the Good obviously had not read the New Testament” (175). Philip III (1396-1467), also known as Philip the Good, sold Joan to the English “for the enormous sum of 10,000 lives tournois” (175). If a person reads the New Testament or at least the Gospel of St. Mark, then he will acknowledge the authenticity of St. Joan’s counsels (64). Thus, because the third objection is a paradox caused by ignorance of the New Testament, the third objection is weak.
Final remarks
The French citizens felt controlled by the barbarians. Thankfully, St. Joan wanted “to rid her land of the evil forces which occupied it” (162).
© By Theodore Faulders, August 10, 2026.