Logical Analysis: Deduction
The final cause of some Church leaders is to have justice. Steven Cook, a victim of crimes of trespasses, said, “I want to see the church rid itself of this kind of vermin, this kind of evil!” (116). Further, Cook said, “I won’t accept anything less that his resignation and a public apology” (116). If a person is hurt by a predator Church leader, then he will want justice. The Lord said, “Beati qui esuriunt et sitiunt justitiam : quoniam ipsi saturabuntur.” – Blessed are they that hunger and thirst after justice: for they shall have their fill” (Mt 5: 6). The term “justice” is defined as “the impartial adjustment of conflicting claims” (Webster’s Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 1228). Mr. Cook hungered and desired justice. Further, Aristotle writes, “When what has been suffered has been measured, one part is called the victim’s loss, and the other is the offender’s profit. The intermediate between loss and profit is the equal… And so the judge tries to restore this unjust situation to equality, since it is unequal” (Nichomachean Ethics, 5, 4). Mr. Cook wanted to “restore the unjust situation” and have the offender resign and apologize. Further, St. Thomas Aquinas writes, “Because the just thing is a mean between gain and loss, it follows that, when men are in doubt about the mean, they have recourse to a judge. A judge ought to be, as it were, living justice, such that his soul is entirely possessed by justice” (Commentary of NE, no. 955). Mr. Cook needed “a judge” in the Catholic Church, such as a bishop or pope, to repair the loss by commanding the predator to resign and to apologize publicly. Thus, because Mr. Cook became a victim in the Church without justice, and because no bishop or pope removed the lawbreaker or commanded the predator to apologize publicly and leave his ministry, some Church leaders are stupid, venal and cowardly.
The material cause of some Church leaders is power. Berry writes, “Silence was a powerful force in ecclesiastical culture” (25). The term “silence” is defined as “a failure to make something known; a tacit omission” (Webster’s Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 2117). Further, Berry writes, “The evidence of things unsaid shadowed assumptions of power” (37). Some Church leaders use their power to remain silent about lawbreakers inside the Church, fail to report offenders to the police, and use silence to expand their power. Further, according to Francis Morrisey, a canon lawyer in Ottawa, said, “I feel as if our entire system is ‘corrupt’ in the sense that at times it appears to based more on power struggles than gospel values” (70). Some Church leaders are “corrupt” (70) and expand their personal power rather than use their power to humbly lead Catholics to the sacraments. Further, according to Fr. Thomas Doyle, O.P., some Church leaders “pursue ecclesiastical power at the expense of laypeople” (110). Some Church leaders proudly use laypeople to increase their personal power.
Further, Berry writes, “A moral order has been broken” (276). Some Church leads have broken their proper and trusting relationship with laypeople. Further, according to Fr. Doyle, “The deadliest symptom is the unbridles addiction to power” (293). Some Church leaders are addicted to power and show their addiction by keeping silent about offenders. Further, James Carroll, an author of twenty books, said, “A power structure that is accountable only to itself will always end by abusing the powerless” (302). Some Church leaders “abuse” (302) laypeople to expand their personal power and “turn a blind eye” (35) to the laity’s “thirst after justice” (Mt 5: 6). Thus, because some Church leaders fail to report offending Church employees to the police, then use silence to expand their power, do not use their power to humbly lead Catholics to the sacraments, “abuse” (302) laypeople to increase their personal power, break the “moral order” (276) with laity, seem addicted to power (293), and “abuse the powerless” (302), some Church leaders are stupid, venal and cowardly.
The formal cause of some Church leaders is powerlessness and a failure to protect the law. A canon lawyer in Rome said, “A social attitude was antinomian and against the law” (65). Some Church leaders have an “attitude” that was “against the law” (65). Further, the canon lawyer in Rome said, “The U.S. tribunals violated grandly, terribly, the annulments of marriage” (65). Some Church leaders violated the law “grandly, terribly” (65). Further, the canon lawyer in Rome said, “The attitude here in 1989, at the Holy See, was that you have legal provisions. Use them!” (66). The term “provision” is defined as “any of various laws enacted in the 13th and early 14th centuries by the assemblies of the English prelates and nobles” (Webster’s Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 1827). Some Church leaders fail to use “laws enacted in the 13th and 14th centuries” (1827) to “restore unjust situations to equality” (Aristotle, NE 5, 4).
Further, Berry writes, The Vatican has “complaints about church tribunals authorizing annulments without proper procedure” (238). Some Church leaders are not using “proper procedures” in the Church courts “tribunals” and courts. Further, Berry writes, “Documents that Demarest obtained in discovery showed a deep hole of corruption” (237). Sylvia Demarest, a lawyer in Dallas, discovered a “deep hole of corruption” when reading Church documents. Thus, because some Church leaders have an attitude that was “against the law” (65), violate the law “grandly, terribly” (65), fail to use laws “to restore this unjust situation to equality” (Aristotle, NE 5, 4), do not use proper procedures in the Church courts “tribunals” (238), and have “a deep hole of corruption” (237), some Church leaders are stupid, venal and cowardly.
The principal agent of some Church leaders is the Lord. According to the Prophet Malachi, the Lord said, “Rex magnus ego, dicit Dominus exercituum, et nomen meum horribile in gentibus.” – “I am a great King, saith the Lord of hosts, and my name is dreadful among the Gentiles” (1: 14). The term “king” is defined as “one that holds a supreme or preeminent position in a particular sphere” (Webster’s Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 1244). The Lord has “supreme” power in His “particular sphere” and the Church. Further, according to St. Matthew, the Lord said, “Et ego dico tibi, quia tu es Petrus, et super hanc petram aedificabo Ecclesiam meam, et portae inferi non praevalebunt adversus eam.” – “And I say to thee: That thou art Peter; and upon this rock I will build my church, and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it” (Mt 16: 18). The term “build” is defined as “to form by ordering and uniting materials by gradual means into a composite whole” (Webster’s Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 291). The Lord orders and unites “materials,” such as clergy and sacraments, around St. Peter and the Pope. Further, according to St. Mathew, the Lord said, “Dico enim vobis, quia nisi abundaverit justitia vestra plus quam scribarum, et pharisaeorum, non intrabitis in regnum caelorum.” – “For I tell you, that unless your justice abound more than that of the scribes and Pharisees, you shall not enter into the kingdom of heaven” (5: 20). Every Catholic must have a strong sense of “justice” (Mt 5: 20) and desire the “mean between gain and loss” (St. Thomas, no. 955). Thus, because some Church leaders do not accept the Lord’s “supreme position” (1244) in the Church, do not accept the Lord’s “form by ordering and uniting materials” (291), and do not have a strong sense of “justice” (Mt 5: 20), some Church leaders are stupid, venal and cowardly.
The preparing agent of some Church leaders is Rome. Berry writes, “The lines of responsibility flowed back to Rome” (7). Loyal Catholics expect the Pope to be like Pope St. Pius V (1504-1572) who loved the Lord, obeyed His Scriptures, safeguarded and protected the law, acknowledged victims of crimes, and punished offenders. Further, Berry writes, “Rome never dreamed that a pathological underworld would be exposed in common law countries, Australia, North America, and Ireland, across the 1990s” (71). Pope John Paul II entered the top leadership position on October 16, 1978 and found the Church has “a pathological underworld” (71) composed of a neglect of the Lord, ignorance of the Scriptures, broken laws, neglected victims, and promoted lawbreakers. Further, Andrew Greeley wrote in 1993,” What a terrible mess we have made out of the priesthood in the years since the Council. Horrible leadership—stupid, venal and cowardly” (82). Pope John Paul II discovered in 1978 that the Church has “stupid, venal, and cowardly” (82) leaders with a priesthood in “a terrible mess” (82). Further, Berry writes, “The Vatican remained passive” (82). The good news is that Pope John Paul II became a superior leader on the global stage and successfully prepared Ronald Reagan (1911-2004), Margaret Thatcher (1925-2013), Mikhail Gorbachev (1931-2022), and Wojciech Jaruzelski (1923-2014) to move away from communism toward free market economies in 1989. The bad news is that Pope John Paul was a weak leader in the Lord’s “particular sphere” (1244) and in the Church. Further, Berry writes, “Why did the pontiff most sophisticated in using mass media fail to resolve a crisis so damaging to the church?” (100). Since Pope John Paul II was a genius at preparing world leaders and directing the media toward free market economies, some Catholics felt disappointed when he was unable to prepare equality for victims and punishments for lawbreakers inside the Church. Further, Berry writes, “Andrew Greeley in 1993 estimated the abuse victims in the U.S. at one hundred thousand” (101). While Pope John Paul II focused on the millions of victims trapped by atheistic communism, he neglected the 100,000 victims inside the Church. Thus, because Pope John Paul II was a Church leader who failed to fix the “pathological underworld” (71), did not throw out “stupid, venal and cowardly” (82) bishops and priests, was unable to prepare equality for victims and punishments for lawbreakers, and neglected one hundred thousand victims inside the Church, some Church leaders are stupid, venal and cowardly.
The assisting agent of some Church leaders is the Vatican. Berry writes, “In Maciel, we confront a papal cover-up. His career is a case study in distorting the truth to gain power and fabricating a virtuous image our of pathological behavior. But the Vatican assisted the process for years” (8). Marcial Maciel Degollado (1920-2008) was a Church leader who offended victims for many years. On May 1, 2010, Pope Leo XIV wrote, “The very grave and objectively immoral actions of Father Maciel, confirmed by accurate testimonies, constitute real crimes and manifest a life devoid of scruples and authentic religious meaning” (“Communiqué”). The Vatican “assisted” Maciel for sixty years until 2010 as he offended over 170 victims. Further, Berry writes, “The clerical system had sheltered hundreds of guilty men while trampling on the rights of their victims” (292). Thus, because some Church leaders in the Vatican “assisted” (8) the criminal Maciel and “hundreds of guilty men” (292), ignored “accurate testimonies” and “real crimes” (“Communiqué”), and crushed the “rights of their victims” (292), some Church leaders are stupid, venal and cowardly.
The four instrumental agents of some Church leaders are secrecy, high-priced lawyers, expensive public relations firms, and money. Berry writes, “Pope John Paul II rewarded several men who personified the Vatican’s corrosive secrecy” (305). The term “corrosive” is defined as “the fatigue of a material that may cause the fracture of the material” (Webster’s Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 512). Some Church leaders failed to publicly care for victims and publicly punish offenders which “fractured” (512) the trust of loyal Catholics. Further, Fr. Doyle wrote, “The dioceses spend tens of millions of dollars on the highest-priced lawyers and hire the best public relations firms to fight” victims (278). For example, in 2024, the Archdiocese used “high-priced lawyers” (278), such as Raymond Boucher of Bourcher LLP, Michael Reck of Jeff Anderson and Associates, Spencer Lucas of Panish Shea LLP, and Morgan Stewart from Manly, Stewart and Finaldi. Further, Berry writes, “On January 6, 2002, The Boston Globe began the series that set off a global chain reaction” (276). When the brave writers at the The Boston Globe found 789 victims and 250 lawbreakers in the Church, Rasky Baerlein Strategic Communications in Boston served as the “best public relations firm” (278) for the Archdiocese of Boston. Further, Berry writes, “Where virtue fails, money sometimes succeeds” (90). The Catholic Church in Boston sold churches and paid $150.8 million to one thousand victims in settlements in 2005. Thus, because some Church leaders use “corrosive secrecy” (305) to protect rather than punish offenders, “fractured” (512) the trust loyal Catholics, “spend tens of millions of dollars on the highest-priced lawyers and the best public relations firms” (278) to protect lawbreakers, and spend millions of dollars in legal penalties to hide “failed virtue” (90), some Church leaders are stupid, venal and cowardly.
The nine counseling agents of some Catholic leaders are St. Bernard of Clairvaux, Aristotle, St. Thomas Aquinas, Pope John XXIII, Ray Mouton, Andrew Greeley, Fr. Thomas Doyle, FBI agent Frank Keating, and Cardinal Pio Laghi. St. Bernard of Clairvaux (1090-1153) told Pope Eugenius III, “Raise your hand to the guilty, since a lack of punishment breeds recklessness that opens the door to all kinds of excess” (10). St. Bernard encouraged the Pope to punish “the guilty” (10). Further, Aristotle suggests that the Pope should “restore this unjust situation to equality” (NE 5, 4). Further, St. Thomas suggests that the Pope find “a mean between gain and loss” (Comm. NE, 955). Further, Pope John XXIII writes, “Advantage to religious vows and ordination should be barred to those who are afflicted with evil tendencies to homosexuality or pederasty, since for them the common life and the priestly ministry would constitute serious dangers” (Instruction, January 23, 1961). Further, Ray Mouton, lawyer for some victims, writes, “The Roman Catholic Church cannot credibly exert moral authority externally where the public perceives it as incapable of maintaining moral authority internally” (57). The Catholic Church’s silence about victims and offenders has corroded and fractured the Catholic Church’s power to influence loyal Catholic and world leaders. Further, Andrew Greeley writes, “Doesn’t anyone tell the cardinals that to the average citizen such silence looks like an admission of guilt” (83). If some Church leaders remain silent about the victims and offenders inside the Church, then some Church leaders appear guilty.
Further, Fr. Doyle writes, “If the bishops dealt with the problem publicly, for the benefit of victims, then we wouldn’t have this crisis” (109). If some Church leaders published daily a list of offender bishops and offender priests who were punished, incarcerated, fined, and thrown out of the Church, then “we wouldn’t have this crisis” (109). Further, Frank Keating, an FBI agent, writes, “For every single act of abuse of a minor, the offending priest will be permanently removed from ministry” (292). Every Church leader who has broken once the Seventh Commandment with a minor should be punished and “removed from ministry” (292). Further, Cardinal Pio Laghi (1922-2009) wrote in 1981 “admonishing the U.S. bishops for their lack of respect toward the church and the magisterium” (23). Laghi blamed the U.S. bishops for not safeguarding and protecting canon law, Church authority and “the magisterium” (23). Thus, because some Catholic leaders fail to punish “the guilty” (10), fail to restore unjust situations (NE 5, 4), fail to find “a mean between gain and loss” (Comm. NE, 955), fail to bar men “with evil tendencies” from seminaries and parishes (Instruction, January 23, 1961), fail to maintain “moral authority internally” (57), fail to prevent their “admission of guilt” (83), fail to deal “with the problem publicly” (109), fail to “permanently remove from ministry” (292) every Church offender, and fail to “respect the church and the magisterium” (23), some Church leaders are stupid, venal and cowardly.
Logical Analysis: Induction
The three inductions of some Church leaders is observed by Fr. Thomas Doyle, a Desert Father, and Steve Rubino. Berry writes, “Fr. Doyle had seen religious communities torn by cliques along lines of sexual orientation” (30). People “afflicted with evil tendencies” (Instruction, 1961) have “torn” and destroyed “religious communities” (30). Further, according to Isaac from Thebaid, “Do not bring boys here. Boys were the reason why four monasteries in Scetis were deserted” (Desert Fathers, Ward, 2003, p. 96). Men “afflicted with evil tendencies” destroyed four monasteries in 250 AD. Further, Berry writes, “After years of legal battles with the church, Rubino was appalled at the ecclesiastical culture” (114). Steve Rubino, a lawyer for victims, was “appalled” (114) and shocked by lack of morals in some Church leaders. Thus, because some Church leaders allow men “afflicted with evil tendencies” (Instruction, 1961) to destroy “religious communities” (30), ignore how men “with evil tendencies” destroyed “four monasteries” in 250 AD, and shock lawyers by their lack of morals, some Church leaders are stupid, venal and cowardly.
The history of some Church leaders shows how they had four opportunities to prevent the loss of money and the destruction of institutions. Berry writes, “Father X pointed to the 1960s as the origin of the crisis when there was “a time of disillusion over authority” (65). In the 1960s the Church leaders lacked caution and did not safeguard and protect the law. Further, Berry writes, “Pope John Paul II, his bishops, and his advisers in the Roman Curia could have arrested the crisis years ago had they heeded the warnings of a prophet in their midst. The Reverend Thomas P. Doyle, a Dominican priest, worked as canon lawyer in the Vatican embassy in Washington, D.C., in the early 1980s. No individual had played a more catalytic role in seeking justice than Father Doyle” (8). In the 1980s Pope John Paul II did not listen to Fr. Doyle and did not save hundreds of millions of dollars awarded to victims. Further, Berry writes, “A Dallas jury awarded $119.6 million in compensation to the victims” of Church leaders. “Doyle delivered a handwritten note to the Dallas diocese and said, ‘Please admit your guilt and allow these young men to get on with their lives’” (241). In 1997 Pope John Paul II did not listen to Fr. Doyle and did not direct the leaders of the Dallas diocese to publicly “admit” their guilt (241). Further, Berry writes, “The Boston Globe, in January 2002, began excavating the criminal history of the archdiocese” of Boston (50). In 2002 Pope John Paul II did not listen to the reporters at the Boston Globe and did not prevent the loss of $150.8 million to one thousand victims in settlements in 2005. Thus, because some Church leaders failed to safeguard and protect the law in the 1960s, failed to listen to Fr. Doyle in the 1980s, failed to admit their guilt publicly in 1997, and failed to listen to the reporters from the Boston Globe in 2002, some Church leaders are stupid, venal and cowardly.
The four analogies suggest that some Church leaders are like the Kremlin, glue, a dark cloud, and a shipwreck. Berry writes, “The Roman Catholic hierarchy was as political as Congress or the Kremlin” (27). Just as the Kremlin uses disinformation campaigns and secret meetings, and just as Congress uses secret contacts and off-the-record meetings, so, too, the Church hierarchy uses “corrosive secrecy” (305), work “against the law” (65), hide “incriminating documents” (110) and expand personal power “at the expense of laypeople” (110). Steve Rubino said, “I’m setting a pattern – the obstruction of justice” (110). Further, Berry writes, “Doyle saw bishops using defense attorneys like codependent glue” (111). Just as glue is used to fasten and join materials together, so, too, some Church leaders are glued to “defense attorneys” and “the best public relations firms” (278) in order to avoid victims and offenders. Further, Berry writes, “The Vatican’s inertia over Groer hovered like a bad cloud. John Paul did not reflect on the damage done by Goer” (231). Hans Groer was a Church leader who was guilty of offending numerous victims in the 1980s. However, Pope John Paul II did not punish Groer and instead made Groer an Archbishop and a Cardinal. As a result, Catholics in Austria felt “a bad cloud” (231) and “betrayal” (231) when Pope John Paul II visited Austria in 1998. Further, Berry writes, Steven Holenstien, “a computer network administrator,” “said, ‘It’s a spiritual shipwreck’” (286) in relation to his New Jersey parish. The term “shipwreck” is defined as “the destruction or loss by sinking or being cast ashore or driven against the rocks of a ship” (Webster’s Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 2098). Just as a ship can be damaged by sinking, landing on the shore, or by hitting rocks, so, too, the Catholic Church can be damaged by “corrosive secrecy” (305), by violating the law “grandly, terribly” (65), and by “a deep hole of corruption” (237). Thus, because some Church leaders use “corrosive secrecy” (305), work “against the law” (65), hide “incriminating documents” (110) like the Kremlin, and because some Church leaders choose “the obstruction of justice” (110), use “defense attorneys like codependent glue” (111), hover over lay people “like a bad cloud” (231), do not “reflect on the damage done” (231) by lawbreakers, and cause “the destruction or loss” of the Church, some Church leaders are stupid, venal and cowardly.
The sign with the message that some Church leaders are irresponsible is how they recycle lawbreakers rather than remove them from ministry. Berry writes, “Geoghan left more than 130 victims across a string of parishes, starting in 1962. Shuffled on to new rectories, he was sheltered from responsibility for his crimes” (50). Some Church leaders employed Geoghan again and again since 1962. Further, Berry writes, “By early 1986, with reports on cases in Australia and Canada, Doyle realized that recycling child molesters was rooted in governing mentality” (53). Some Church leaders in the U.S., Australia and Canada recovered child molesters rather than remove them from ministry. Further, Berry writes, “What gnawed at Doyle’s insides was the cold, imperious assumption that when a priest violated a kid, the church rallied to defend, hide, and reassign that priest” (108). Some Church leaders defend offenders of victims, hide offenders and “reassign” the offenders to new parishes.
Further, Steve Rubino asked, “How did American priests morally justify reassigning offenders?” (109). American priests should understand and appreciate the supreme law of the United States. According to the U.S. Constitution, “the Senate and House of Representatives may punish its Members for disorderly Behavior, and, with the Concurrence of two thirds, expel a Member” (1787, Article I, Section 5). Rubino wonders how American Church leaders are “reassigning offenders” (109) rather than punish or expel them “for disorderly behavior” (1787, I, 5). Further, Berry writes, “Clerical privilege is fueled by the recycling of perpetrators” (110). The “recycling of perpetrators” (110) is a sign with the message that some Church leaders wish to expand their personal power rather than use their power to humbly lead Catholics to the sacraments. Further, Berry writes, “Bishop Frank Rodimer of Paterson, New Jersey, had recycled perpetrators” (287). Thus, because some Church leaders allowed Geoghan to leave “more than 130 victims across a string of parishes” (50), have the policy of “recycling child molesters” (53), prefer to “defend, hide, and reassign” lawbreakers (108), fail to punish or expel offenders “for disorderly behavior” (1787, I, 5), and expand their personal power by “recycling of perpetrators” (110), some Church leaders are stupid, venal and cowardly.
The one motive of some Church leaders is to use force against whistleblowers. Berry writes, “Cardinal Baggio tried to block Bernardin’s candidacy… When demoted by John Paul, Baggio moaned, ‘I am nothing in the Curia now – nothing’” (26). Cardinal Sebastiano Baggio (1913-1993) reasonably understood that Bernardin was a lawbreaker but was “demoted by John Paul” (26) when he reported misconduct. Further, Berry writes, Fr. Eugene Kennedy warned bishops about homosexuals, but the bishops “put them back into the clerical culture. That culture is now in shards” (34). In 1970 when Fr. Kennedy reasonably warned bishops about the misconduct of priests “afflicted with evil tendencies” (Instruction, January 23, 1961) the bishops counterattacked Kennedy and placed the lawbreakers “back into clerical culture” (34). Further, Berry writes, “Doyle wanted bishops to stop recycling perpetrators. The bishop should remove the cleric from the parish” (46). But “when the bishops met for their June 1985 fathering, Doyle realized the fix was in” (48). Fr. Doyle reasonably encouraged bishops to stop recycling lawbreakers and to start removing them from ministry. However, he “realized” (48) that the bishops do not care what happens “when a priest molests a child” (48).
Further, Berry writes, “Fr. Bruce Ritter, found of Covenant House was accused of abuse by young men. And a priest who reported three accusations to the archdiocese about Fr. Ritter, he was told to keep quiet” (72). When a priest reasonably warned the New York Archdiocese about the lawbreaker Fr. Ritter he “was told to keep quiet” (72). Further, Berry writes, “Husband and wife, conservative Catholics from Chicago, were attorneys” (80). When their seven year old son was abused by the pastor, they reasonably demanded that the Archdiocese “create a lay review board to deal with such priests. The archdiocese said no.” (80). Further, Berry writes, “In 1976, a lay brother named Ted Oswald helped several families report Fr. Trupia [an offender priest] to the bishop. Trumpia was packed off to Tucson. Oswald sent the families’ complaints to Tucson. The diocese destroyed them and the chancellor rebuked Oswald for making trouble” (233). Ted Oswald reasonable helped families report the crimes of Fr. Trupia. And when Fr. Trupia was reassigned in Tucson, Oswald reasonably sent his report of the crimes of Fr. Trupia to Tucson. But Oswald was told by by a Church leader to stop “making trouble” (233) and Oswald’s report was “destroyed” (233). Thus, because some Church leaders are motivated to “demote” (26) Cardinal Baggio when he reasonably tried “to block Bernardin’s candidacy” (26), counterattacked Fr. Kennedy when he reasonably warned bishops about priests “afflicted with evil tendencies” (Instruction, January 23, 1961), fail to listen to Fr. Doyle who reasonably encouraged bishops to stop employing lawbreakers and to start removing child molesters from ministry, tell a priest “to keep quiet” (72) who reasonably reported accusations about an offender priest, say “No” (80) to two Catholic lawyers who reasonably suggested that a lay review board be created to deal with offender priests, and destroy the reasonable reports by Oswald about a lawbreakers, some Church leaders are stupid, venal and cowardly.
The passions involved with some Catholic leaders are love, hope, anger, embarrassment, despair, fear, and anxiety. Berry writes, “Fr. Doyle loved the Latin mass” (15). Further, Berry writes, “The pope placed hope in such fundamentalist movements as Opus Dei which began in Spain, the Italians group Communione e Liberazione, and the Legionaires of Christ from Mexico” (37). Pope John Paul II saw the contempt for authority in some bishops and hoped “fundamentalist movements” (37) would be loyal to the magisterium. Unfortunately, Pope John Paul II was busy with global politics and did not realize that the three groups has numerous lawbreakers. Further, Berry writes, “Enflamed by the idea of priests molesting children, Oddi stated that the Vatican would issue a decree” (47). Cardinal Silvio Oddi (1910-2001) was “the head of the Congregation for the Clergy” (47) and become angry when learning about offender priests. Further, Berry writes, “Margaret Gallant had several nephews who were abused by Geoghan. She had written to Cardinal Humberto Medeiros and said, ‘It embarrasses me that the church is so negligent’” (51). Margaret Gallant felt “embarrassed” (51) and horrified by the lack of virtue of some Church leaders who are “negligent” (51) about victims.
Further, Berry writes, “Andrew Greeley heard from an anguished father in Northbrook. He despaired of church governance” (81). Greeley talked with a father of a victim and felt despair and pain when he recalled that “the entire system is corrupt” (70). Further, Berry writes, “Fr. Doyle said, “I believe there was a fear that the secrecy that is so much an important part of the Roman Catholic Church would have been violated” (240). Fr. Doyle realizes that some Church leaders are fearful about how their corruption their secrets will be revealed in the court cases involving lawbreakers. Further, Fr. Doyle writes, “Surely there must me some in leadership roles who appreciate the pain of survivors and the need for institutional honesty, but where?” (274). Fr. Doyle hopes that some Church leaders have care for victims, punishment for offenders, and honesty for parishioners. Further, Berry writes, Father Roqueni said simply, ‘They don’t care’” (299). Fr. Roqueni presented a victim to Archbishop Luigi De Magistris (1922-2022) in Rome in 1999. Sadly, De Magistris said, “But I am not the person to whom you should go” (299). Thus, because some Church leaders discourage love for “the Latin mass” (15), place hope in sketchy “fundamentalist movements” (37), become angry about offender priests (47), trigger “embarrassment” (51) in parents of victims, trigger despair in “an anguished father” (70), cause fear when realizing the secrets of corruption will be court cases (240), weaken the hope that some leaders will care for “survivors” and be “honest” about corruption (274), and trigger anxiety when realizing that some leaders “don’t care” (299) about victims, some Church leaders are stupid, venal and cowardly.
The statistic concerning some Church leaders is 87%. Berry writes, “A USA Today poll found that 87 percent of Catholics surveyed wanted bishops who had concealed child molesters to step down” (291). If a bishop “concealed” (291) an offender priest and “recycled child molesters” (53), then the bishop should do the responsible thing and “step down” (291). Thus, because some Church leaders ignore 87% of Catholics and do not “step down” (291) after “recycled child molesters” (53), some Church leaders are stupid, venal and cowardly.
Logical Analysis: Deception
The Fallacy of a Lack of Imagination states that a conclusion is false, because the premise cannot be imagined. For example, “I can't imagine how X could be true; therefore, X must be false.” Berry writes, “Michael Peterson went to Rome in March, 1986, hoping to persuade Curial officials of the need for binding norms on removing child molesters” (54). After the meeting with Curial officials, Peterson said, “They don’t get it” (54). Similarly, the Curial officials are probably concluding, I cannot imagine how ‘bishops recycling child molesters’ could be true. Therefore, ‘bishops recycling child molesters’ is false.
The Fallacy of Ad Hominem states that a conclusion is false, since the person making the premise is corrupt. For example, a patient can reject a doctor’s advice to quit smoking simply because the doctor smokes. Berry writes, “James Serritella, a huge, shambling man who had helped stonewall the federal investigation of Cardinal Cody, brayed, ‘What you people have to remember is that those people’ – the families – ‘are the enemy’” (57). Serritella rejects the conclusion that some families are victims of clergy abuse, because some families “are the enemy” and corrupt. Sadly, Serritella ignores the logic that families of victims have “suffered” a “loss” caused by an “offender” who is employed by the Church (Aristotle, NE, 5, 4).
The Fallacy of a Paradox states that a conclusion is opposed to common sense. Berry writes, “The paradox is awesome. The pope who championed freedom from political dictatorships turned a cold shoulder to human rights within the church” (300). Just as Pope John Paul II was concerned about the citizens in fifteen countries who lost their rights by evil dictators, so, too, he should have been concerned about citizens in Catholic parishes who lost their innocence by evil child molesters. But Pope John Paul II was not concerned about victims in the Church. And this seems frustrating to loyal Catholics and common sense.
Ethical Analysis
The personality of some Church leaders involves denial. Berry writes, “Saint Peter Damian in 1051 sent a famous tract denouncing homosexual activity among clergy to Pope Leo IX, who thanked him and ignored it” (34). The term “denial” is defined as “refusal to admit the truth of a statement or charge” (Webster’s Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 602). In 1051 Pope Leo IX refused “to admit the truth” of St. Peter Damian’s “tract” (24) and essay. Further, Berry writes, “The allegation that the founder of an international religious order was a pederast, and that his organization used brainwashing techniques, met a cool Roman silence” (4). In 1976 Pope Paul VI refused to admit the truth about “the founder” (4) of “the Legionaires of Christ from Mexico” (37). Further, Fr. Alarcon writes, “It’s amazing. There are big people in Rome who are avoiding this” (5). In 1997 Pope John Paul II refused to admit the truth that Fr. Maciel was a lawbreakers. Further, Berry writes, “As gays swelled the ranks of seminaries and clergy in the 1980s, Rome largely turned a blind eye” (35). In the 1980s Pope John Paul II refused to admit the truth about men “afflicted with evil tendencies” (Instruction, 1961).
Further, Richard Sipe writes, “There is not other single element so destructive to sexual responsibility among clergy as the system of secrecy, which shields behavior and reinforces denial” (35). Richard Sipe, “a psychotherapist and former Benedictine priest” (35), stated that lawbreakers are protected by “secrecy” (35) and “denial” (35). Further, Berry writes, “By early 1986, with reports on cases in Australia and Canada, Doyle realized that recycling child molesters was rooted in a governing mentality… Walls of denial came with the territory” (53). In 1986 Pope John Paul II and his Cardinals refused to admit the truth about “recycling child molesters” (53) and put up “walls of denial” (53). Further, Berry writes, “Cardinal Bernardin wrote from Chicago, chastising him for speaking publicly on the topic” (57). In 1986 Cardinal Bernardine refused to admit the truth about “pedophilia” (57) and told Fr. Doyle to stop talking about lawbreakers in the Church. Further, Coldrey writes, “Rome was in denial in the mid-nineties” (104). In the mid 1990s Barry Coldrey, a Christian Brother and historian in Australia, discovered that the “people in Rome” (104) refused to admit the charge that some bishops and some priests are lawbreakers and should be removed from ministry.
Further, Berry writes, “Bishop Grahmann refused to leave and no one in Rome ordered his to do so” (242). Bishop Charles Grahmann recycled child molesters in the Diocese of Dallas. In 1997 a jury “awarded a staggering $101 million in compensation to the victims” (241). After a child molester priest “began a long prison term” (242), Grahmann refused to admit the truth of the charge, refused “to leave” (241) and was ignored by Church leaders in Rome. Thus, because some Church leaders have denial and refuse to admit the truth of “Saint Peter Damian’s famous tract” (45), refused to admit that Fr. Maciel “was a pederast” (4), refused to admit the charge of Fr. Felix Alarcon (5), refused to admit the truth about men “afflicted with evil tendencies” (Instruction, 1961) in the 1980s (35), refused to admit the truth of Richard Sipe’s statement about how secrecy and denial show and admission of guilt (35), put up “walls of denial” in 1986 (53), refused to admit the truth about “pedophilia” in the clergy (57), refused to admit the charge that some Church leaders are pederasts and should be removed from ministry (104), and refused to remove Bishop Grahmann from ministry (241), some Church leaders are stupid, venal and cowardly.
The consciences of some Church leaders seem to be turned off. Berry writes, “When a priest violated a kid, the church rallied to defend, hide, and reassign the priest” (108). The term “violate” is defined as “to do harm to the person” (Webster’s Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 2254). If a priest harms a child, then justice demands that the victim is restored and the offender is punished. Thus, because some Church leaders prefer to “defend, hide a reassign” the offender rather than punish him, some Church leaders are stupid, venal and cowardly.
It is necessary to have some Church leaders who are trustworthy. Berry writes, “Doyle realized that there was a crisis in a system he was only beginning to fathom. Whom do you trust?” (49). “Doyle wanted bishops to stop recycling perpetrators” (48) and some Church leaders refused to admit Doyle’s wish. Thus, because some Church leaders refused “to stop recycling perpetrators” (48), and because some Church leaders broke the trust of loyal Catholics, some Church leaders are necessarily stupid, venal and cowardly.
The possibility that some Church leaders have a failed strategy is real. Berry writes, some Church leaders “emulate John Paul’s response to sexual corruption: keep quiet, deny, apologize if necessary, and when in doubt, attack the messenger” (280). The term “strategy” is defined as “the art of devising or employing plans or stratagems toward a goal” (Webster’s Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 2256). The final cause is justice. The Lord said, “Beati qui esuriunt et sitiunt justitiam : quoniam ipsi saturabuntur.” – Blessed are they that hunger and thirst after justice: for they shall have their fill” (Mt 5: 6). The plan to arrive a justice involves finding the “mean between gain and loss” (Commentary of NE, no. 955) which requires reasons, precedents and judges. Thus, because some Church leaders fail to arrive a justice with reasons, precedents, and judges, and because some Church leaders plan to arrive at justice with secrets, denial, silence, and insults toward the victim, some Church leaders are possibly stupid, venal and cowardly.
The conjecture is that some Church leaders need oversight. Berry writes, “The Roman Catholic Church desperately needs a separation of powers. The canonical courts are hardly independent. The church has no oversight mechanism to remove bishops and priests who grossly betray the trust of the faithful” (302). The term “oversight” is defined as “watchful care; general supervision” (Webster’s Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 1610). If bishops are “recycling child molesters” (53) and if “no one in Rome orders” (242) lawbreakers to leave the ministry, then it seems reasonable to suggest that a higher “supervision” (1610) is needed. Thus, because some Church leaders “grossly betray the trust of the faithful” (302) and fail to accept “general supervision” (1610), some Church leaders are stupid, venal and cowardly.
The foresight of some Church leader seems to be turned off. Berry writes, “Catholics could forgive if the church were honest” (43). If some Church leaders had foresight and saw the value of admitting how they wrongfully recycled “child molesters” (53), then some Catholics “could forgive” them (43). Further, Ray Mouton said, “The Church needs a plan” (44). Mouton is a lawyer for victims and realized that some Church leaders have a failed strategy and need a new strategy. Further, Berry writes, Doyle was “unable to persuade the hierarchy that a torrent of violations would unleash volcanic winds” (55). Some Church leaders are not ready to face the “volcanic winds” (55) in the future caused by their “recycling child molesters” (53) since the 1970s. Further, Doyle said, “If we don’t act now, the consequences will be catastrophic” (57). Some Church leaders lack foresight and cannot see the catastrophe that will result when the Catholic Church loses its “moral authority” (57). Further, Berry writes, “Cannon was struck by the authors’ foresight. How fantastically dumb the bishops had been to ignore their advice” (62). In 1987 Carl Cannon, a “reporter for the San Jose Mercury News” (61), found “thirty-five priests in twenty-four dioceses” (62) who were “recycled child molesters” (53). Cannon received Doyle’s report called “The Problem of Sexual Molestation by Roman Catholic Clergy” (1985) and realized that some Church leaders lacked foresight and were “dumb” to “ignore” the report (62). Further, Berry writes, “If the Vatican’s blindness continues, the church will see a continued loss of numbers and declining credibility in the countries on which it relies for financial support” (307). Some Church leaders remain in denial, lack foresight and will lose “numbers” of loyal Catholics and “financial support” (307). Thus, because some Church leaders lack foresight, cannot be “honest” (43), don’t have “a plan” (44) for punishing lawbreakers, fail to see the “volcanic winds” (55) on the horizon, fail to see “catastrophic” (5) consequences of “recycling child molesters” (53), refuse to admit the truth of Doyle’s 1985 report, “The Problem of Sexual Molestation by Roman Catholic Clergy” (62), and fail to understand that secrecy and denial decrease the number of parishioners and “financial support” (307), some Church leaders are stupid, venal and cowardly.
The circumspection of some Church leaders seems to be turned off. Berry writes, “A culture of political correctness took root as the agenda of gay apologists collided with orthodox teaching” (36). The term “circumspect” is defined as “marked by earnest attention to all significant circumstances and possible consequences of action” (Webster’s Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 410). Thus, because some Church leaders failed to be circumspect, did not give “earnest attention” (410) to “the one hundred thousand abuse victims in the U.S.” (101), failed to acknowledge the “possible consequences” (410) of “thirty-five priests in twenty-four dioceses” (62) who were “recycled child molesters” (53), and failed to safeguard and protect Pope John XXIII’s Instruction about lawbreakers “afflicted with evil tendencies” (1961), some Church leaders are stupid, venal and cowardly.
The caution of some Church leaders seems to be turned off. Berry writes, “Doyle was bothered by the mind-set that viewed concerns from the rank and file as a nuisance” (44). The term “nuisance” is defined as “an offensive, annoying, unpleasant, or obnoxious thing” (Webster’s Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 1548). It seems that loyal Catholics are a problem, since “the rank and file” (44) seem to force some Church leaders to be secretive and use “the highest-priced lawyers” (278). However, some Church leaders are confused, since it is their lack of conscience, lack of foresight, lack of circumspection and lack of caution which causes them to be irresponsible, “annoying, unpleasant” (1548). Thus, because some Church leaders lack caution and conclude that loyal Catholics are “a nuisance” (44), “annoying and unpleasant” (1548), some Church leaders are stupid, venal and cowardly.
Freedom
I shall now use my freedom and review the above analysis. Hmm… I shall now use my freedom and choose my two favorite reasons. I have decided that I prefer the material cause and the formal cause. I shall now use my freedom to express my choice with an enthymeme. Because some Church leaders use “silence” (25) and “a failure to make something known; a tacit omission” (Webster’s Third New International Dictionary, 1966, p. 2117), and because some Church leaders fail to safeguard and protect the law, some Church leaders are stupid, venal and cowardly.
Objections
The first objection is that Pope John Paul II is innocent. George Weigel writes, Many American bishops were “unwilling to speak openly and candidly about this problem to John Paul and the Curia” (99). The response to the first objection is to say that Pope John Paul II shares the guilt of some Church leaders. Berry writes, “Contrary to Weigel’s scapegoat theory, the crisis grew from a history of sexual secrecy demanded by the papacy” (99). Pope John Paul II failed to fix the “pathological underworld” (71) and did not remove the “stupid, venal and cowardly” (82) bishops and priests.
The second objection states that “The church has never ignored the problem of sexual abuse” (278). The response to the second objection is to state that “the governing elite of an organization will eventually think it is the organization” (278). Some Church leaders fail to understand that simply acknowledging a lawbreaker is different than actually punishing the lawbreaker.
The third objection is that the “Vatican views the American church as a victim of a witch hunt by the media” (284). The response to the third objection is from Pope John Paul II who said, “The advice of the clinical experts led bishops to make decisions which subsequent events showed to be wrong” (289). Some Church leaders lack the virtues of conscience, foresight, circumspection, caution, honesty, and accountability. As a result, some Church leaders made “wrong” decisions (289).
The fourth objection is that “many studies attest that gay people cannot choose their sexual orientation” (303). The response to the fourth objection is to state that many studies show that homosexuality is not natural. Further, studies show that gay people are freely tricked into “a narcissistic fixation” (59) by demons. Archbishop Julian Herranz correctly said in 2002, “The concrete form of homosexuality is pedophilia” (306). Further, Doyle writes, “It is precisely this clerical narcissism that produced the crises in the first place” (279).
The fifth objection is stated by Roger Mahoney, a Church leader in Los Angeles, who said in 2013, “I can’t recall a time such as now when people tend to be so judgmental and even self-righteous, so quick to accuse, judge and condemn. And often with scant real facts and information” (Los Angeles Times, Victoria Kim, Feb. 26, 2013). Mahoney does not understand why some “rank and file” (44) Catholics are criticizing him. The response to the fifth objection is to say that Mahoney is a Church leader in denial and cannot accepted accountability. In 2024 a jury with “real facts and information” awarded $880 million to 1,353 victims of child molester priests in the Archdiocese of Los Angeles.
Final remarks
Fr. Doyle hopes that some Church leaders have concern for victims, punishment for offenders, and honesty for parishioners. Thankfully, the Lord does.
© by Theodore Faulders, September 1, 2026